“A racist is a racist regardless of if it is a comedian or not”: The fate of Chubby Brown's show

A heated debate by Sheffield City Council took place today (6 October) after a controversial comedian was banned from his show at City Hall.

The meeting sparked flames as they voted against a 40,000 strong petition to allow comedian, Roy Chubby Brown’s, show to go ahead as planned.

The debate was initiated after petitioner, Hayley Madden, set up a Change.org page to reverse the Sheffield City Trust’s decision in cancelling the funny man’s show.

Frustrated by the outcome of her petition, Ms Madden said: “I just think it’s absolutely ridiculous. It really is absolutely ridiculous. They’ve not listened to the 7,067 locals that have signed it, they’ve just made the decision up themselves. They’ve not listened to anybody.”

Roy Chubby Brown was due to perform at Sheffield City Hall later this month, and the decision to cancel was not taken lightly with councillors passionately expressing their beliefs on the topic.

Councillor Shaffaq Mohammed, leader of the Liberal Democrats, said: “Who am I to dictate to the rest of the city what they do and what entertainment they enjoy. They can choose to live their life the way they want.”

This was opposed by Councillor Abdistan, who said: “Comedy is subjective, if you don’t like it, don’t go, people say. But this isn’t about putting views down people’s throats.

“This is racism. A racist is a racist, regardless of if it is a comedian or not. Freedom of speech does not mean freedom of consequence.”

In her response, Ms Madden pointed out that the comedian is well known for his charity work, arguing that his efforts in donating the proceeds from his merchandise should alter their perceptions.

Another councillor argued: “It’s about whether you support the fundamental right to freedom of speech.

“Sheffield city council should not be able to decide what we watch. We are supposed to be living in a liberal society. If you don’t like Roy Chubby Brown, don’t go.”

The deputy mayor, Sioned-Mair Richards, said: “I have a legal duty to promote society cohesion. Do I welcome to this city a man who sprinkles his act with the N word or P word? No. I cannot support him coming. I cannot support someone who insults all my fellow citizens.”

(Example of exclusive council/entertainment story from 3rd year news project at university)